Carlisle Tires Review: Best for Specialty Applications
Carlisle is a trusted name in the tire industry. Its tires are famous for their high-quality construction, long-lasting tread life, and superb traction on various surfaces. High puncture resistance and mid-range prices further set them apart from rivals.
Yet there are areas where it could improve. While its tires are a popular choice for ATVs, trailers, UTVs, and heavy-duty industrial machinery, Carlisle has yet to leverage its tire-making expertise in producing tires for passenger cars and commercial trucks.
In this Carlisle tires review, we’ll take a look at the brand’s best-selling tires. We’ll highlight the strengths of these models as well as areas where they could do better. Read on if you’re unsure whether Carlisle tires have what is needed to meet your requirements.
Carlisle Tires Review
Here are the best Carlisle tires currently on the market:
#1. Carlisle Radial Trail HD – Best for Trailers

Price Check
Check the price of this tire at the following retailers:
DiscountTire PriorityTire SimpleTireDon't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
The Carlisle Radial Trail HD is one of the best tires for heavy-load trailers.
This model comes in load range F and can thus handle heavier loads than its competitors, most of which can only go so far as load range E. A thick rubber compound means it’s less likely to suffer cuts, chips, and punctures than its fellow trailer tires.
Unlike cheap generic trailer tires, the Radial Trail HD won’t lose air pressure, regardless of how bad the road conditions may get. Best of all, it comes in speed ratings L and M. This means you can safely drive it at highway speeds without risking your vehicle’s stability.
To further sweeten the deal, Carlisle has weather-protected its rubber. As such, its tread won’t come apart due to overheating, a common issue with heavy-load trailer tires.
Pros
- Available in Load Range F
- Can be safely driven at higher speeds
- Rides pretty smoothly for a highway tire
Cons
- Some owners have reported failure issues on lower load range tires
#2. Carlisle All Trail II ATV – Best UTV Tire for Trail

Price Check
Check the price of this tire at the following retailers:
DiscountTire PriorityTire SimpleTireDon't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
The Carlisle All Trail II ticks several boxes for the average UTV driver who spends most of their time behind the wheel on dirt roads, gravel, and sand.
A large number of lugs and grooves in its tread help offer additional grip on various terrains, including mud, gravel, and uneven surfaces. The grooves between the lugs also play their part in expelling mud, rocks, and other materials that can get clogged in the tread.
The All Trail II has a much more flexible compound than its predecessor. You can thus count on it to offer decent traction on wet surfaces. Another thing that the rubber does is absorb road vibrations, making this tire’s ride incredibly refined.
Pros
- Offers excellent performance on the off-roads
- Performs reliably on paved surfaces
- Boasts a durable tread compound
Cons
- Makes a fair bit of noise
#3. Carlisle Sports Trail LH – Best All-Season Tire for Trailers

Price Check
Check the price of this tire at the following retailers:
DiscountTire PriorityTire SimpleTireDon't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
Available in different load ratings, the Sports Trail LH promises year-round utility and fuel-efficient drives on your trailer.
An all-season tread compound helps this tire come in handy in dry, wet, and light wintry conditions. This means you won’t have to replace this tire (unless driving in thick snow). This is a huge plus point as most all-season tires in this price range are useless in winter.
With multiple circumferential grooves, the risk of aquaplaning is slim. Also, a multiple-ribbed tread pattern optimizes road contact for reduced rolling resistance and improved fuel economy. And you’d also be pleasantly surprised by the steering response on offer.
Pros
- Boasts superb all-weather traction
- Promises a fuel-efficient drive
- Won’t let much noise enter the cabin
Cons
- Not the easiest to mount
#4. Carlisle AT 489 II – Best All-Terrain Tire for ATV

Don't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
Carlisle tires are well-known among ATV drivers for their long-lasting tread life, sturdy construction, and reliable off-road performance. Luckily, the AT 489 II isn’t any different.
Start with the rugged construction. A reinforced tread compound and 6-ply construction make this model puncture- and shock-absorbent, giving it the confidence to conquer harsh terrains. This enhanced strength also ensures a safer driving experience.
Thanks to the high void ratio in its tread, this tire stays clean of sand, dirt and mud. This, in turn, ensures constant road contact, which is crucial for adequate grip and traction. Also, it comes in three ratings, two of which (two and three-star rated) can be used on the road.
Pros
- Maintains a clean footprint
- Can conquer harsh terrains with ease
- Offers superb control in all possible situations
Cons
- A few users complain that they are easy to puncture
#5. Carlisle Turf Saver II – Best for Garden Equipment

Price Check
Check the price of this tire at the following retailers:
DiscountTire PriorityTire SimpleTireDon't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
Searching for a reliable set of tires for your lawn mower? Have no issues with bias-ply tires? If so, the Carlisle Turf Saver II deserves your attention.
This model comes in a bias-ply construction that offers excellent durability (as well as the tendency to deform when left uninflated for a long time). Equally importantly, its rounded shoulders and arrow-head shoulder blocks help it perform well on the turf area without damaging it.
Also, while the bias-ply structure may have made this tire look ugly. It has also enhanced this model’s damage resistance, making it less vulnerable to punctures, cuts, and other damages that can get through your average law mower’s tires and shorten their service life.
Pros
- Can easily withstand heavier weights
- Actively resists cuts, punctures and other damages
- Performs securely on turf surfaces without damaging them
Cons
- May need to hire an expert to have it seated
#6. Carlisle Farm Specialist R-1 – Best for Tractors

Don't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
The Farm Specialist R-1 has everything tractor owners may look for when buying tires for their farm machines.
A high void ratio and angled lug pattern join forces to enhance this model’s traction on soft and loose terrains, which almost every tractor encounters daily. Both guarantee forward motion to ensure that your truck rarely gets stuck.
Additionally, the high void ratio plays the role of the self-cleaner, ejecting sand, mud, and dust particles from the tread. This, in turn, enhances your tractor’s stability. Plus, a reinforced structure minimizes the risk of this model deforming under heavy loads.
Pros
- Offers superb traction on loose terrains
- Can securely carry and withstand heavy loads
- Does an excellent job of resisting cuts, chips, and punctures
Cons
- Costs more than rivals from imported brands
#7. Carlisle Turf Master – Best for Golf Courses

Price Check
Check the price of this tire at the following retailers:
DiscountTire PriorityTire SimpleTireDon't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
If you are looking for dedicated lawn tires that can carry out their job without harming the surface underneath, we’d recommend the Carlisle Turf Master.
A symmetric tread design and advanced rubber compound help this tire in more ways than one. Besides equally spreading out forces of acceleration, braking and cornering, they prevent irregular wear formations for long-lasting tread life.
On comparing this model with other lawn tires, you’d see that it has a wider profile and more rounded shoulders than the competition. This helps this tire maintain turf contact at all times and offer a better steering response for enhanced driving stability.
Pros
- Offers superb traction on loose terrains
- Can securely carry and withstand heavy loads
- Does an excellent job of resisting cuts, chips, and punctures
Cons
- Mounting it may take a lot of time and effort
#8. Carlisle Trac Chief – Best for Industrial Applications

Don't know the correct size tire to purchase? Start here!
If you’re searching for a dependable set of tires for your skid steer, the Trac Chief has what it takes to meet your requirements.
Boasting load ratings that go as high as 8-ply and a reinforced sidewall structure, this model can handle up to 5,000 lbs (per tire) without the load pressure affecting its shape. As a result, you can count on this tire not to deform during usage.
A strong internal structure provides this tire with another benefit. It resists sharp objects from tearing the rubber and damaging the casing. Also, its sidewall is designed in a way to shield the rims from damage, thereby offering a safe driving experience.
Pros
- Comes in a large number of sizes
- Can withstand heavy loads without suffering deformation
- Shields the wheel’s rim and its internal casing from damage
Cons
- May not be the best choice for soggy or soft dirt conditions
Carlisle Tires Buying Guide
What is there to like about Carlisle tires? What is it that distinguishes these tires from the chasing pack? Are there areas where Carlisle Tires could or should have done better? Any shortcomings that could potentially be deal-breakers? This section has all the answers.
Why Should You Buy Carlisle Tires?
Here’s why Carlisle Tires should be on your short list of tire brands to buy next:
1) Wide Range of Specialty Tires
Although it doesn’t manufacture tires for passenger cars, Carlisle produces a wide range of radials for speciality applications, including:
- Lawn and Garden Tires: Carlisle produces a large number of tires designed for garden tractors, lawnmowers, golf carts, and other landscaping equipment. All these tires offer superb stability without damaging the turf.
- Trailer Tires: Whether you own a heavy-duty double-axle trailer or a light-duty utility trailer, Carlisle has you covered. Its trailer tires can withstand heavy loads, have long-lasting tread life, and have brilliant stability.
- Agricultural tires: Carlisle manufactures a wide range of tires for multiple kinds of agricultural machinery. These tires offer traction in soggy field conditions, withstand heavy loads, and minimize soil compaction.
2) Excellent Value for Money
While the price of Carlisle tires varies based on their size and intended use, you can generally expect to get a good value on your investment. That is especially the case when you compare the performance, durability, and performance of these radials with counterparts from other brands.
Need proof? Check out the Carlisle Trail Radial HD. Despite being one of the best tires for trailers, this model costs less than counterparts from rival brands.
3) Standard Workmanship and Defects Guarantee
Although designed for specific applications, Carlisle tires’ workmanship and defects guarantee rival those you get on passenger car tires from other brands.
If a material or quality defect makes your Carlisle tire unserviceable within two years of purchase, the company will replace it without charging you a penny.
Why Should You Not Buy Carlisle Tires?
Here’s why Carlisle Tires may not be the right option for you:
No Options for Passenger Car and SUV Owners
Like its rival brand Maxxis, Carlisle has put all its eggs in the speciality tire basket, with zero models for passenger cars, SUVs, and light trucks. This makes these tires a no-go area for everyday use.
Frequently Asked Questions
Who makes Carlisle tires?
The Carlstar Group, a subsidiary of Carlisle Companies Incorporated, makes Carlisle tires. The Carlstar group was founded in 1998 as a joint venture between Carlisle Companies and Sumitomo Rubber Industries. It has production facilities all over the world.
Where are Carlisle tires made?
Carlisle Tires are manufactured in production facilities in the United States and China. Two of its production facilities are in the US, including one in Jackson, Tennessee, and one in Clinton, Tennessee.
How long do Carlisle tires last?
Various factors (i.e., the type of tire, the amount of use, and the conditions in which you drive it) influence the lifespan of a Carlisle tire. However, in most cases, the average lifespan of a Carlisle tire is between 3 and 8 years.
Is Carlisle a good brand?
Carlisle is a world-renowned tire brand for specialty tires. It produces high-quality tires for lawn and garden equipment, utility trailers, construction, agriculture, industrial vehicles, and recreational vehicles.
Are Carlisle tires noisy?
Generally speaking, Carlisle tires tend to be quiet. However, there are some factors that can make any tire loud, including the tread pattern. For instance, tires with an open tread pattern tend to make more noise than those with a closed tread pattern.
Are Carlisle tires good for snow?
Carlisle offers various tires for harsh wintry conditions, including Snow Hog, Maxx Winter, and XTRAC.
Conclusion
If you’re searching for the best tires for trailers, lawn and agricultural equipment or industrial machinery, Carlisle has you sorted. Also, since Carlisle tires are less susceptible to failure or blowing, they are ideal for heavy-duty applications.